Skip to content
scentateca

Discover

Tools

Everything in the catalogue, filterable by note, accord and season.

All fragrances
Appearance
Library
scentateca

Compare · 2 fragrances

How your fragrances compare

Listed notes, wearer reports and available prices, side by side.

Radical Brown Man

Eau de ParfumArmaf

Herod

Eau de ParfumParfums de Marly

Before you buy

From a 85% community match (middle value of every % people gave or implied) and what people say

Overlap: People rate these 80% alike or more, so owning both is likely to feel redundant.

Sample first? Sample Radical Brown Man first. If it works on your skin, you may not need Herod.

Performance, per people

  • Radical Brown Man falls short: Short longevity (about 5 hours) and weak projection 1210
  • Radical Brown Man falls short: Shorter longevity and weaker projection than Herod 9
  • Radical Brown Man falls short: Weak longevity, like Herod 3

When to wear, per people

  • Radical Brown Man does better: Brighter, more versatile for warm weather 9

At a glance

How long it lasts

Not enough wearer reports to compare how long they last

Only Herod has enough reports so far

Radical Brown ManNo reports yet
HerodWeakFrom 48 wearer mentions
Source detailsSource: drawn from imported review text, not direct votes on this site · From 48 wearer mentions; text interpretation can miss context · calculated 2026-10-26

How far it projects

Not enough wearer reports to compare how far they project

Only Herod has enough reports so far

Radical Brown ManNo reports yet
HerodIntimateFrom 24 wearer mentions · limited
Source detailsSource: drawn from imported review text, not direct votes on this site · From 24 wearer mentions · limited; text interpretation can miss context · calculated 2026-10-26

Price per ml

Not enough prices to compare per ml

Only Herod has a listed price

Radical Brown ManNo price listed yet
Herod$3.20 per ml$400 · 125 ml · bottle offer
Source detailsListed bottle offer. Price and stock may change; confirm with the retailer.

Seasons

Not enough season data to compare

Only Herod has seasons listed

Radical Brown ManNo seasons listed yet
HerodWinter

Day or night

Not enough wearer reports to compare day and night

From day and night mentions in wearer reports

Radical Brown ManNo reports yet
HerodMostly night

Scent families

All lean woody

Woody is in the top 3 accords of every fragrance

Radical Brown ManAmber · Aromatic · Woody
HerodWoody · Warm Spicy · Campfire

What they share

Notes as listed for each fragrance · 16 different notes in total

4 notes shared by both

CinnamonCistusIncensePepper

What makes each different

Notes listed only by one fragrance in this comparison

Radical Brown Man

11 notes listed · 7 unique here

AmberCedar-WoodGeraniumLavenderLemonTobaccoVetiver

Herod

9 notes listed · 5 unique here

CedarwoodMusksOsmanthusTobacco LeafVanilla

Accords side by side

Relative strength within each fragrance

Amber

Radical Brown Manstrong
Herodmedium

Woody

Radical Brown Manstrong
Herodstrong

Warm Spicy

Radical Brown Manstrong
Herodstrong

Aromatic

Radical Brown Manstrong
HerodNot listed

Campfire

Radical Brown Manmedium
Herodmedium

Mulled Wine

Radical Brown ManNot listed
Herodmedium

Tobacco

Radical Brown Manmedium
Herodmedium

Stored-pair evidence

Herod is the original; Radical Brown Man is the listed alternative.

  • CloseOpening
  • Same familyHeart
  • Same familyDry-down

Checking sign-in…

Batches and reformulations vary, so test on skin before you buy.

See all alternatives to Herod

What the community says

From 13 community sources · High confidence

Community match
85%
Middle value of every % people gave or implied
Stated by people
80%
Middle value where people said a number

People say: Commenters mostly call Radical Brown a very close, cheap Herod clone (80 to 95 percent), though some see a blend with L'Homme Ideal or Black Orient, a more synthetic vanilla and short longevity.

Where people say Radical Brown Man does better

  • Much cheaper at roughly $30-40 9111
  • Much cheaper; some prefer it to Herod 25
  • Brighter, more versatile for warm weather 9
  • Some owners prefer it over Herod 13

Where people say Radical Brown Man falls short

  • Cheap-feeling bottle; more synthetic vanilla base 91
  • Short longevity (about 5 hours) and weak projection 1210
  • Shorter longevity and weaker projection than Herod 9
  • Weak longevity, like Herod 3

Differences people notice

  • Lacks Herod's vanilla and osmanthus/incense nuance; adds cherry (L'Homme Ideal) and Black Orient touches 917
  • Seen as a Herod and L'Homme Ideal blend rather than a straight clone 8
Show all 13 sources

  1. BlogFragranzo.com80% match, stated by the source

    Armaf Radical (also known as Radical Brown) offers an impressive 80% similarity to Herod at an almost unbelievable price point.

    Best Dupes For Parfums de Marly Herod - Fragranzo (opens in a new tab)

  2. Reddit commentreheter

    Also go try Armaf radical brown. I actually prefer it over Herod.

    Reddit comment in r/Colognes (opens in a new tab)

  3. Reddit commentLumpy-Establishment8

    I also have Armaf Radical Brown which smells good but has shit longevity, just like the OG PDM.

    Reddit comment in r/fragranceclones (opens in a new tab)

  4. Reddit commentEastern_Distance645695% match, read from the wording

    I smelled Herod months later, and they seemed the same.

    Reddit comment in r/fragranceclones (opens in a new tab)

  5. Reddit commentjw_frags85% match, read from the wording

    armaf radical brown is a great cheap one, but it’s similar enough to herod that it’s redundant to have both.

    Reddit comment in r/fragrance (opens in a new tab)

  6. Reddit commentEastern_Distance645685% match, read from the wording

    Armaf Radical Brown is a very good clone of it though

    Reddit comment in r/fragranceclones (opens in a new tab)

  7. YouTubeGents Scents75% match, read from the wording

    This is a sort of clone hybrid of Parfums de Marly Herod and Bvlgari Black Orient.

    One Of Armaf's BEST | Armaf Radical Brown | Bvlgari Black Orient PDM Herod Clone (opens in a new tab)

  8. Reddit commentafireinside9660% match, read from the wording

    I don't think this one is an outright clone but it feels like a blend of PdM Herod and Guerlain L'homme Ideal EDP.

    Reddit comment in r/fragrance (opens in a new tab)

  9. ParfumoMrHonest85% match, read from the wording

    As can be expected, the projection and longevity are nowhere NEAR the strength of Herod, but it's no slouch either, especially if sprayed on clothing. I get about 7 hours total

    Radical Brown by Armaf - Review by MrHonest (opens in a new tab)

  10. YouTube comment@minigouda2024

    don't expect a longevity above 5 hours.

    Armaf radical brown review -Best Parfum de Marly Herod clone (opens in a new tab)

  11. YouTube comment@sameold5050

    Alrighty,let that sink in PDM fan club. Been saying it for years,no need to spend so much $ on fragrance.

    One Of Armaf's BEST | Armaf Radical Brown (opens in a new tab)

  12. YouTube comment@J.M888

    skin scent no power this one... smell really nice but no performance

    Armaf radical brown review -Best Parfum de Marly Herod clone (opens in a new tab)

  13. YouTube comment@Cornelle6319

    I prefer Radical Brown over both. Comparing Radical to Herod is a dis-service to Radical.

    Armaf radical brown review -Best Parfum de Marly Herod clone (opens in a new tab)

What people say about their own bottles, not a guarantee. Batches vary, so test on skin before you buy.