Skip to content
scentateca

Discover

Tools

Everything in the catalogue, filterable by note, accord and season.

All fragrances
Appearance
Library
scentateca

Compare · 2 fragrances

How your fragrances compare

Listed notes, wearer reports and available prices, side by side.

Select Night

Eau de ParfumMercedes-Benz

Noir Extreme

ParfumTom Ford

Before you buy

From a 60% community match (middle value of every % people gave or implied) and what people say

Overlap: People rate these 50–64% alike: related, with clear differences.

Sample first? Sample Select Night for what it is; don't buy it expecting Noir Extreme.

Performance, per people

  • Select Night does better: Performance and projection reported as better than Noir Extreme by several commenters 34
  • Select Night falls short: Weak projection on some wearers 6

At a glance

How long it lasts

Not enough wearer reports to compare how long they last

Only Noir Extreme has enough reports so far

Select NightNo reports yet
Noir ExtremeLong lastingFrom 28 wearer mentions · limited
Source detailsSource: drawn from imported review text, not direct votes on this site · From 28 wearer mentions · limited; text interpretation can miss context · calculated 2026-10-26

How far it projects

Not enough wearer reports to compare how far they project

Only Noir Extreme has enough reports so far

Select NightNo reports yet
Noir ExtremeIntimateFrom 16 wearer mentions · limited
Source detailsSource: drawn from imported review text, not direct votes on this site · From 16 wearer mentions · limited; text interpretation can miss context · calculated 2026-10-26

Price per ml

Not enough prices to compare per ml

Only Noir Extreme has a listed price

Select NightNo price listed yet
Noir Extreme$2.40 per ml$240 · 100 ml · bottle offer
Source detailsListed bottle offer. Price and stock may change; confirm with the retailer.

Seasons

Not enough season data to compare

Only Noir Extreme has seasons listed

Select NightNo seasons listed yet
Noir ExtremeFall · Winter

Day or night

Not enough wearer reports to compare day and night

From day and night mentions in wearer reports

Select NightNo reports yet
Noir ExtremeMostly night

Scent families

All lean woody

Woody is in the top 3 accords of every fragrance

Select NightWoody · Warm Spicy · Citrus
Noir ExtremeWarm Spicy · Woody · Fresh Spicy

What they share

Notes as listed for each fragrance · 16 different notes in total

3 notes shared by both

CardamomSandalwoodVanilla

What makes each different

Notes listed only by one fragrance in this comparison

Select Night

9 notes listed · 6 unique here

BergamotCedarGuaiac WoodLavenderOrange BlossomPatchouli

Noir Extreme

10 notes listed · 7 unique here

GingerGuaiacwoodKulfiNeroli OilRose AbsoluteSaffronTonka Bean

Accords side by side

Relative strength within each fragrance

Warm Spicy

Select Nightmedium
Noir Extremestrong

Woody

Select Nightstrong
Noir Extremestrong

Fresh Spicy

Select Nightlight
Noir Extrememedium

Aromatic

Select Nightmedium
Noir Extrememedium

Citrus

Select Nightmedium
Noir ExtremeNot listed

Vanilla

Select NightNot listed
Noir Extrememedium

Patchouli

Select Nightlight
Noir ExtremeNot listed

Stored-pair evidence

Noir Extreme is the original; Select Night is the listed alternative.

  • CloseOpening
  • CloseHeart
  • CloseDry-down

Checking sign-in…

Batches and reformulations vary, so test on skin before you buy.

See all alternatives to Noir Extreme

What the community says

From YouTube · Medium confidence

Community match
60%
Middle value of every % people gave or implied

People say: YouTube commenters see Select Night as a cheaper Noir Extreme alternative that performs better for some, though not an exact match.

Where people say Select Night does better

  • Performance and projection reported as better than Noir Extreme by several commenters 34
  • Far cheaper than Tom Ford 6

Where people say Select Night falls short

  • Weak projection on some wearers 6
  • One commenter says to buy the Tom Ford instead 5

Differences people notice

  • Called cousins rather than siblings; opening differs, drydown sweet and powdery like Noir Extreme 32
Show all 7 sources

  1. YouTubeJoy Amin

    The Mercedes Benz one is a clone of Noir Extreme and a very good one, let's compare that to the OG and see who wins.

    Tom Ford Noir Extreme Vs Benz Select Night (Comparison) (opens in a new tab)

  2. YouTube comment@f.tscent115860% match, read from the wording

    To my nose in the opining it has a similar vipe to LNDL YSL then it becomes more sweet and powdery like NOIR EXTREME TF

    MERCEDES BENZ SELECT NIGHT..SURPRISED (opens in a new tab)

  3. YouTube comment@mandac512760% match, read from the wording

    I do have TF Noir Extreme and I feel like they aren’t siblings, but perhaps cousins. They are different enough for me to have both. Although I love TF, I just the Mercedes Benz is sexier and the performance is actually way better.

    Mercedes Benz Select Night Review | Inspired by TF Noir Extreme (opens in a new tab)

  4. YouTube comment@uncleunique9053

    Literally better in performance than Tom Ford Noir Extreme

    REALLY GOOD CHEAPIE FOR FALL | MERCEDES-BENZ SELECT NIGHT FRAGRANCE REVIEW (opens in a new tab)

  5. YouTube comment@boongyify

    Save your money and buy the Tom Ford , you will not regret.

    Tom Ford Noir Extreme Vs Benz Select Night (Comparison) (opens in a new tab)

  6. YouTube comment@pumaadidas

    Mercedes select night is weak on me but i like it while tf noir extreme is very expensive but definitely watered down now

    Tom Ford Noir Extreme Vs Benz Select Night (Comparison) (opens in a new tab)

  7. YouTube comment@NinaBinaXO

    I can’t believe I did not realize it was a dupe for TF Noir Extreme, because I love that one too!!

    Tom Ford Noir Extreme Vs Benz Select Night (Comparison) (opens in a new tab)

What people say about their own bottles, not a guarantee. Batches vary, so test on skin before you buy.