Skip to content

Dark Knight vs Black Phantom

Dark Knight is a very close match for Black Phantom. Community match: 90%, from 4 of 5 sources.

You love
Black Phantom by By Kilian
Try
Dark Knight by Alexandria Fragrances
90%Very close
Black PhantomBy KilianFragrance page for Black Phantom
Dark KnightAlexandria FragrancesFragrance page for Dark Knight

Very close overall

Community-rated · 4 of 5 sources gave a %
95+959075

3 prefer Dark Knight · 2 prefer Black Phantom

What changes with Dark Knight

Wearer points first, then what notes and accords show.

+ You gain

  • Much cheaperWearers
  • Lasts longerCommunity reports
  • Adds vetiver and patchouliFrom notes & accords
  • More patchouliFrom notes & accords

− You give up

  • Less rich and deep, can get cloyingWearers
  • Much less almondFrom notes & accords
  • No caramel or heliotropeFrom notes & accords
  • Much less caramelFrom notes & accords
  • Less coffeeFrom notes & accords

What wearers say

Where Black Phantom wins2 prefer it

  • Less rich and deep, can get cloying

Where Dark Knight wins3 prefer it

  • Much cheaper

Both sides noticed

  • Less coffee/chocolate and more smoky in one view

Accords

Predicted from notes. Highlighted rows differ, and a note one side lacks explains it.

  • SweetSweet: Black Phantom 100 of 100, Dark Knight 83 of 100, a clear difference
  • ChocolateChocolate: Black Phantom 73 of 100, Dark Knight 100 of 100
  • Almondnot listedAlmond: Black Phantom 93 of 100, Dark Knight not listed, a clear difference
  • Mulled WineMulled Wine: Black Phantom 52 of 100, Dark Knight 74 of 100
  • WoodyWoody: Black Phantom 36 of 100, Dark Knight 71 of 100
  • Warm SpicyWarm Spicy: Black Phantom 39 of 100, Dark Knight 64 of 100
  • Caramelnot listedCaramel: Black Phantom 61 of 100, Dark Knight not listed, a clear difference
  • not listedPatchouliPatchouli: Black Phantom not listed, Dark Knight 60 of 100, a clear difference
  • Coffeenot listedCoffee: Black Phantom 49 of 100, Dark Knight not listed, a clear difference

5 more accords with no clear difference

Notes

Only Black Phantom 4

  • Caramel
  • Heliotrope
  • Almond
  • Coffee

Only Dark Knight 2

  • Vetiver
  • Patchouli

Matched after merging spelling and origin variants.

PerformanceCommunity reports

  • long lastingLongevitylong lastingLongevity: Black Phantom long lasting, Dark Knight long lasting

Smelled both? How close are they?

How close

Checking sign-in…

What looks wrong?