Naughty Girl vs Good Girl
Naughty Girl is a close alternative to Good Girl. Model read from notes and accords, with no community % yet.
Good GirlCarolina HerreraFragrance page for Good Girl
Naughty GirlAlexandria FragrancesFragrance page for Naughty Girl
Close overall
Estimated · early community read
Not community-rated yet, so no %. The tier is our estimate until reviewers weigh in.
1 prefer Naughty Girl · 0 prefer Good Girl
What changes with Naughty Girl
Wearer points first, then what notes and accords show.
＋ You gain
- Much stronger and longer lasting than Good GirlWearers
- CheaperWearers
- Adds vanilla and coffeeFrom notes & accords
- More coffeeFrom notes & accords
- More vanillaFrom notes & accords
− You give up
- Much less tuberoseFrom notes & accords
- Much less white floralFrom notes & accords
- No cocoa or tuberoseFrom notes & accords
What wearers say
Where Good Girl wins
Nothing reported
Where Naughty Girl wins1 prefer it
- Much stronger and longer lasting than Good Girl
- Cheaper
Both sides noticed
- Drier, spicier drydown than Good Girl's sweeter one
Accords
Predicted from notes. Highlighted rows differ, and a note one side lacks explains it.
- SweetSweet: Good Girl 100 of 100, Naughty Girl 100 of 100
- White FloralWhite Floral: Good Girl 81 of 100, Naughty Girl 35 of 100, a clear difference
- TuberoseTuberose: Good Girl 76 of 100, Naughty Girl not listed, a clear difference
- VanillaVanilla: Good Girl 43 of 100, Naughty Girl 69 of 100, a clear difference
- BakeryBakery: Good Girl 58 of 100, Naughty Girl 63 of 100
- AlmondAlmond: Good Girl 38 of 100, Naughty Girl 55 of 100
- ChocolateChocolate: Good Girl 50 of 100, Naughty Girl 49 of 100
- CoffeeCoffee: Good Girl not listed, Naughty Girl 47 of 100, a clear difference
- Warm SpicyWarm Spicy: Good Girl 21 of 100, Naughty Girl 43 of 100, a clear difference
5 more accords with no clear difference
Notes
Only Good Girl 3
- Cocoa
- Tuberose
- Jasmin Sambac
Only Naughty Girl 9
- Vanilla
- Coffee
- Jasmine
- Cacao
- Praline
- Orange Blossom
- Rose Petals
- Bergamot
- Lemons
Matched after merging spelling and origin variants.
Smelled both? How close are they?
Checking sign-in…