Amber Oud Carbon Edition vs Green Irish Tweed
Amber Oud Carbon Edition is its own take on Green Irish Tweed. Community match: 60%, from 4 of 5 sources.
Green Irish TweedCreedFragrance page for Green Irish Tweed
Amber Oud Carbon EditionAl HaramainFragrance page for Amber Oud Carbon Edition
Own take overall
Community-rated · 4 of 5 sources gave a %
85754525
2 prefer Amber Oud Carbon Edition · 2 prefer Green Irish Tweed · 1 no preference
What changes with Amber Oud Carbon Edition
Wearer points first, then what notes and accords show.
＋ You gain
- Pleasant, smooth drydown liked by some; ambergris baseWearers
- Aromatic-ledFrom notes & accords
- Adds moss and cedarFrom notes & accords
- More aquaticFrom notes & accords
- A touch zestierFrom notes & accords
− You give up
- Darker, missing GIT's green freshnessWearers
- No sandalwood or oakmossFrom notes & accords
- Less citrusFrom notes & accords
What wearers say
Where Green Irish Tweed wins2 prefer it
- Darker, missing GIT's green freshness
Where Amber Oud Carbon Edition wins2 prefer it
- Pleasant, smooth drydown liked by some; ambergris base
Both sides noticed
- Reads as a mix of Cool Water, Aspen and GIT
Accords
Predicted from notes. Highlighted rows differ, and a note one side lacks explains it.
- CitrusCitrus: Green Irish Tweed 100 of 100, Amber Oud Carbon Edition 68 of 100, a clear difference
- AromaticAromatic: Green Irish Tweed 80 of 100, Amber Oud Carbon Edition 100 of 100, a clear difference
- GreenGreen: Green Irish Tweed 95 of 100, Amber Oud Carbon Edition not listed, a clear difference
- WoodyWoody: Green Irish Tweed 84 of 100, Amber Oud Carbon Edition 88 of 100
- Fresh SpicyFresh Spicy: Green Irish Tweed 62 of 100, Amber Oud Carbon Edition 81 of 100
- LavenderLavender: Green Irish Tweed 32 of 100, Amber Oud Carbon Edition 75 of 100
- AmberAmber: Green Irish Tweed 35 of 100, Amber Oud Carbon Edition 63 of 100, a clear difference
- HerbalHerbal: Green Irish Tweed 24 of 100, Amber Oud Carbon Edition 50 of 100
- AquaticAquatic: Green Irish Tweed not listed, Amber Oud Carbon Edition 39 of 100, a clear difference
6 more accords with no clear difference
Notes
Only Green Irish Tweed 9
- Sandalwood
- Oakmoss
- Ambroxan
- Cedarwood
- Violet
- Verbena
- Galbanum
- Lemon
- Peppermint
Only Amber Oud Carbon Edition 7
- Moss
- Cedar
- Vetiver
- Amber
- Sea Notes
- Sage
- Rosemary
Matched after merging spelling and origin variants.
Smelled both? How close are they?
Checking sign-in…