Cool Water vs Green Irish Tweed
Cool Water is a close alternative to Green Irish Tweed. Community match: 85%, from 5 of 10 sources.
Green Irish TweedCreedFragrance page for Green Irish Tweed
Cool WaterDavidoffFragrance page for Cool Water
Close overall
Community-rated · 5 of 10 sources gave a %
9595856025
1 prefer Cool Water · 4 prefer Green Irish Tweed · 5 no preference
What changes with Cool Water
Wearer points first, then what notes and accords show.
＋ You gain
- Far cheaperWearers
- Vintage formulation seen as an improvement on GITWearers
- Fruity-ledFrom notes & accords
- Much more floralFrom notes & accords
- Much sweeterFrom notes & accords
− You give up
- Current formulation less like GIT and less good than the originalWearers
- Fades much faster (about an hour)Wearers
- More synthetic smellWearers
- Much less citrusFrom notes & accords
- Much less greenFrom notes & accords
What wearers say
Where Green Irish Tweed wins4 prefer it
- Current formulation less like GIT and less good than the original
- Fades much faster (about an hour)
- More synthetic smell
Where Cool Water wins1 prefer it
- Far cheaper
- Vintage formulation seen as an improvement on GIT
Both sides noticed
- Same perfumer; vintage Cool Water is closer to GIT than the current version
- Resemblance is mostly in the drydown
Accords
Predicted from notes. Highlighted rows differ, and a note one side lacks explains it.
- CitrusCitrus: Green Irish Tweed 100 of 100, Cool Water 27 of 100, a clear difference
- FruityFruity: Green Irish Tweed not listed, Cool Water 100 of 100, a clear difference
- GreenGreen: Green Irish Tweed 95 of 100, Cool Water not listed, a clear difference
- WoodyWoody: Green Irish Tweed 84 of 100, Cool Water 30 of 100
- FloralFloral: Green Irish Tweed not listed, Cool Water 81 of 100, a clear difference
- FreshFresh: Green Irish Tweed 42 of 100, Cool Water 80 of 100
- AromaticAromatic: Green Irish Tweed 80 of 100, Cool Water not listed, a clear difference
- SweetSweet: Green Irish Tweed not listed, Cool Water 69 of 100
11 more accords with no clear difference
Notes
Only Green Irish Tweed 10
- Oakmoss
- Ambroxan
- Cedarwood
- Lavender
- Violet
- Geranium
- Verbena
- Bergamot
- Galbanum
- Peppermint
Only Cool Water 19
- Musk
- Peach
- Raspberry
- Vanilla
- Vetiver
- Violet Root
- Lotus
- Hawthorn
- Honey
- Jasmine
- Lily of the Valley
- Rose
- Water Lily
- Black Currant
- Calone
- Lily
- Melon
- Pineapple
- Quince
Matched after merging spelling and origin variants.
PerformanceCommunity reports
- LongevityLongevity: Green Irish Tweed moderate, Cool Water moderate
Smelled both? How close are they?
Checking sign-in…