Montaigne Vanille vs Roses Vanille
Montaigne Vanille is a close alternative to Roses Vanille. Community match: 85%, from 2 of 5 sources.
Roses VanilleManceraFragrance page for Roses Vanille
Montaigne VanilleMaison AlhambraFragrance page for Montaigne Vanille
Close overall
Community-rated · 2 of 5 sources gave a %
8585
1 prefer Montaigne Vanille · 1 prefer Roses Vanille · 3 no preference
What changes with Montaigne Vanille
Wearer points first, then what notes and accords show.
＋ You gain
- Much cheaper than the originalWearers
− You give up
- Owner still prefers Roses Vanille; longevity only decentWearers
- Fades soonerCommunity reports
- Much less sweetFrom notes & accords
- No sugar or dew dropFrom notes & accords
- Less bakeryFrom notes & accords
What wearers say
Where Roses Vanille wins1 prefer it
- Owner still prefers Roses Vanille; longevity only decent
Where Montaigne Vanille wins1 prefer it
- Much cheaper than the original
Accords
Predicted from notes. Highlighted rows differ, and a note one side lacks explains it.
- VanillaVanilla: Roses Vanille 100 of 100, Montaigne Vanille 77 of 100, a clear difference
- RoseRose: Roses Vanille 99 of 100, Montaigne Vanille 100 of 100
- WoodyWoody: Roses Vanille 96 of 100, Montaigne Vanille 80 of 100
- SweetSweet: Roses Vanille 72 of 100, Montaigne Vanille 21 of 100, a clear difference
- MuskyMusky: Roses Vanille 68 of 100, Montaigne Vanille 39 of 100
- PowderyPowdery: Roses Vanille 58 of 100, Montaigne Vanille 62 of 100
- CitrusCitrus: Roses Vanille 45 of 100, Montaigne Vanille 52 of 100
- BakeryBakery: Roses Vanille 44 of 100, Montaigne Vanille not listed, a clear difference
4 more accords with no clear difference
Notes
Only Roses Vanille 2
- Sugar
- Dew Drop
Only Montaigne Vanille 0
None
Matched after merging spelling and origin variants.
PerformanceCommunity reports
- LongevityLongevity: Roses Vanille long lasting, Montaigne Vanille moderate
Smelled both? How close are they?
Checking sign-in…