Cumbria vs Carlisle
Cumbria is a close alternative to Carlisle. Model read from notes and accords, with no community % yet.
CarlisleParfums de MarlyFragrance page for Carlisle
CumbriaThe DUA BrandFragrance page for Cumbria
Close overall
Estimated · early community read
Not community-rated yet, so no %. The tier is our estimate until reviewers weigh in.
1 prefer Cumbria · 0 prefer Carlisle
What changes with Cumbria
Wearer points first, then what notes and accords show.
＋ You gain
- Longevity of 8-10 hours, sometimes beating CarlisleWearers
- Much cheaperWearers
− You give up
- No opopanax resinoid or davanaFrom notes & accords
- Much less floralFrom notes & accords
- Much less balsamicFrom notes & accords
What wearers say
Where Carlisle wins
Nothing reported
Where Cumbria wins1 prefer it
- Longevity of 8-10 hours, sometimes beating Carlisle
- Much cheaper
Both sides noticed
- Dry down has more amber and less patchouli
Accords
Predicted from notes. Highlighted rows differ, and a note one side lacks explains it.
- FruityFruity: Carlisle 100 of 100, Cumbria 92 of 100
- VanillaVanilla: Carlisle 44 of 100, Cumbria 100 of 100
- Warm SpicyWarm Spicy: Carlisle 62 of 100, Cumbria 86 of 100
- SweetSweet: Carlisle 63 of 100, Cumbria 67 of 100
- PatchouliPatchouli: Carlisle 51 of 100, Cumbria 66 of 100
- FloralFloral: Carlisle 57 of 100, Cumbria 18 of 100, a clear difference
- Mulled WineMulled Wine: Carlisle 55 of 100, Cumbria 55 of 100
- BalsamicBalsamic: Carlisle 54 of 100, Cumbria not listed, a clear difference
- AmberAmber: Carlisle 42 of 100, Cumbria not listed, a clear difference
6 more accords with no clear difference
Notes
Only Carlisle 4
- Opopanax Resinoid
- Davana
- Osmanthus
- Saffron
Only Cumbria 0
None
Matched after merging spelling and origin variants.
Smelled both? How close are they?
Checking sign-in…