Tobacco Noir vs Herod
Tobacco Noir is a very close match for Herod. Community match: 95%, from 2 of 4 sources.
HerodParfums de MarlyFragrance page for Herod
Tobacco NoirMontagne ParfumsFragrance page for Tobacco Noir
Very close overall · Closest in the opening · dry-down drifts
Community-rated · 2 of 4 sources gave a %
9595
2 prefer Tobacco Noir · 0 prefer Herod · 2 no preference
What changes with Tobacco Noir
Wearer points first, then what notes and accords show.
＋ You gain
- Much cheaper, around $40 for 50mlWearers
− You give up
- Slightly less full/dense than Herod; weaker projectionWearers
- Much less woodyFrom notes & accords
- No cedarwood or osmanthusFrom notes & accords
What wearers say
Where Herod wins
- Slightly less full/dense than Herod; weaker projection
Where Tobacco Noir wins2 prefer it
- Much cheaper, around $40 for 50ml
Accords
Predicted from notes. Highlighted rows differ, and a note one side lacks explains it.
- WoodyWoody: Herod 100 of 100, Tobacco Noir not listed, a clear difference
- TobaccoTobacco: Herod 53 of 100, Tobacco Noir 100 of 100
- Warm SpicyWarm Spicy: Herod 77 of 100, Tobacco Noir 99 of 100
- VanillaVanilla: Herod not listed, Tobacco Noir 88 of 100
- SmokySmoky: Herod 44 of 100, Tobacco Noir 77 of 100
- CampfireCampfire: Herod 60 of 100, Tobacco Noir 72 of 100
- Mulled WineMulled Wine: Herod 59 of 100, Tobacco Noir 61 of 100
- MuskyMusky: Herod 36 of 100, Tobacco Noir 56 of 100
6 more accords with no clear difference
Notes
Only Herod 3
- Cedarwood
- Osmanthus
- Cistus
Only Tobacco Noir 0
None
Matched after merging spelling and origin variants.
Smelled both? How close are they?
Checking sign-in…